Sepia drawing of a tabby cat sitting tall with eyes closed and a contented smile, wearing a small spiral pendant.Rhiannon Welton

A Compare and Contrast

No Fear in Love: God’s Design for Intimacy and the Counterfeit That Mimics It

A compare-and-contrast built around 1 John 4:18

Created October 2026

Why I’m Writing This

I am not writing this from a distance. I know darkness, and I know light, and I have wrestled with both. I know what it is to be drawn toward something that promises what the heart is hungry for, and I know the weight of finding out it cannot keep its promise. I also know what it is to be met by Jesus, and to discover that His way is not a smaller, safer version of what the world offers. It is the real thing and so much profoundly better, deeper, anand rewarding.

I do not write this to shame anyone, and I do not write it from above anyone. If you have walked in the darkness this paper describes, I am not pointing a finger. I am holding out a hand. Paul says God comforts us in our troubles so that we can comfort others with the comfort we have received from Him (2 Corinthians 1:3-4). This is my attempt to do that.

Here is what I believe. What God designed for marriage is the authentic, beautiful, real deal: love with nothing to fear, closeness with nothing to hide, and a joy that does not leave you emptier afterward. The counterfeit is the opposite. It is fearsome and deceitful. It promises freedom and delivers bondage. (John 10:10).

I say all of this in love: love for the person who is tired of the dark, love for the marriage that has not yet seen the light, and love for the One who has always been the light. Jesus said, “I am the light of the world. The one who follows Me will never walk in the darkness but will have the light of life” (John 8:12). And to those of us who know where we came from, Paul says, “You were once darkness, but now you are light in the Lord. Walk as children of light” (Ephesians 5:8).

The Heart of It

God made marital intimacy to be the safest, most freeing, most joy-filled union two people can ever know. BDSM offers a counterfeit of it. It replaces the surrender, the closeness and the release we were made to find in marriage, building on restraint, pain, and mastery, and it leans on the sensation (or the staging) of fear to work. The whole contrast comes down to one verse:

[glow] There is no fear in love; instead, perfect love drives out fear, because fear involves punishment. So the one who fears has not reached perfection in love.

IThe Verse at the Center

There is no fear in love; instead, perfect love drives out fear, because fear involves punishment. So the one who fears has not reached perfection in love.

1 John 4:18 (HCSB)

John is speaking about our whole life with God, but he states a principle about love itself. Notice two things. First, the Greek word behind “punishment” (kolasis) carries the idea of torment, correction by pain. John ties fear and punishment together as a pair. Second, “perfect” means complete, love that has reached its goal. Love that has reached its goal does not threaten. It welcomes.

Then comes verse 19: “We love because He first loved us.” Love is first received, then given. It grows in safety, not under threat.

Applied to intimacy, the question is simple. If love is perfect, what is left to be afraid of? Not rejection, not punishment, not being hurt. God’s design leaves nothing to fear. The counterfeit keeps the fear, or its costume, because it needs it.

IIFrom Eden to the Cross

The first picture of intimacy in Scripture is total exposure with total safety: “The man and his wife were both naked, yet felt no shame” (Genesis 2:25). Nothing hidden, nothing feared.

Then sin enters. In Genesis 3:7-10 Adam and Eve sew coverings and hide from God, and Adam’s first recorded words afterward are, in essence, “I was afraid, because I was naked, so I hid.” Fear and nakedness become tangled together. Every distortion of intimacy since has lived somewhere on that line: hiding, shame, control, fear.

Satan’s method has never changed. Jesus says the thief comes to steal, kill and destroy (John 10:10), and Paul warns that Satan disguises himself as an angel of light (2 Corinthians 11:14). He offers a counterfeit of the very thing the heart was made for, and delivers it through a trap.

Then there is Jesus. He came to free “those who were held in slavery all their lives by the fear of death” (Hebrews 2:14-15). We did not receive a spirit of slavery leading to fear, but the Spirit of adoption (Romans 8:15), a spirit of power, love and self-control (2 Timothy 1:7). In a lot of spiritual ways, the gospel brings the Eden condition: naked and unafraid. Marriage is where that restoration gets lived out between two people.

IIIWhat God Designed
  • Safe to be fully known. One flesh, naked and unashamed (Genesis 2:24-25).
  • Delight commanded and celebrated. A newly married husband is released from war for a year “to bring happiness to his wife” (Deuteronomy 24:5). “Be intoxicated always with her love” (Proverbs 5:18-19). The whole Song of Solomon.
  • Invited, never forced. Three times Song of Solomon says not to awaken love until it pleases (2:7; 3:5; 8:4). The bride opens the garden herself (4:16). The beloved knocks (5:2), just as the Bridegroom stands at the door and knocks in Revelation 3:20. He does not break the door down.
  • Mutual. “I am my beloved’s and my beloved is mine” (Song of Solomon 6:3). Husband and wife owe each other love and do not withhold it (1 Corinthians 7:3-5).
  • Honored. Each “in holiness and honor,” not in lustful passion like those who do not know God (1 Thessalonians 4:3-5). The marriage bed is held in honor (Hebrews 13:4).
  • Cherishing. A husband “nourishes and cherishes” his wife as his own body (Ephesians 5:28-29). The Greek word for cherish means to warm.
  • A mystery that points to Christ. “This mystery is profound, but I am talking about Christ and the church” (Ephesians 5:32). What happens in a holy marriage bed is a picture of the Bridegroom and His bride.
IVWhat the Counterfeit Borrows, and Where It Breaks

The needs behind it are real, and God put them there: to surrender and be held, to be completely known, to be released from the pressure of always being in control, to feel deeply alive. The counterfeit meets those needs with the wrong tools. It uses restraint where God designed embrace, pain where He designed tenderness, ownership where He designed belonging, and negotiated roles where He designed covenant.

It also has to stage danger in order to feel trust. A safe word is a thoughtful tool, but look at what it admits: the experience can go too far, so an emergency exit is needed. In covenant love, safety is not an exit. It is the atmosphere from the first moment, secured by a promise made before God. Perfect love never needs the exit.

VThe Attitude Behind the Act

The darkness here is not only physical. It is an attitude. Humiliation, degradation and “mastery” all trade on treating a person made in God’s image as less than a person (Genesis 1:27; James 3:9).

Scripture sets a different standard:

What we rehearse shapes us. Proverbs 4:23 says to guard the heart, because everything flows from it, and Romans 12:2 says the mind is renewed or reshaped by what we give it. Images and scripts of contempt, repeated, train the heart toward contempt, even when they are labeled play.

Pain belongs to the same story. It enters Scripture as part of the curse (Genesis 3:16-19) and is wiped away in the new creation (Revelation 21:4). God’s design for sex has no place for pain as an ingredient. Pain is the curse’s, not the gift’s.

VIWhat the Body Says

Fear and trust speak different languages in the body. Fear and pain trigger the stress response: racing heart, stress hormones, tensed muscles. The body also answers overload by releasing its own painkillers and by pulling the mind away from the moment. People in this world describe a floaty, detached, euphoric haze often called “sub space.” That can look less like two people becoming one and more like the mind stepping away from what is happening.

Psychologists have also documented that the alarm of fear can be misread by the mind as attraction. Intensity is not the same as intimacy. A pounding heart does not prove closeness.

God’s design runs the other way. The body relaxes, opens and stays present, because it is safe. “One flesh” (Genesis 2:24) requires both people fully there, not escaping. The high that comes from fleeing the moment is not the same joy as being completely known and loved in it.

VIIWounds, Not Just Wickedness

This needs to be said with humility. Every one of us has desires bent by the Fall, including the “socially accepted as normal” kinds (Matthew 5:28; Romans 3:23). Nothing here is an accusation from a pedestal, and Scripture does not let us read another person’s heart.

But Scripture does give a lens: a broken design often reaches for the right thing in the wrong way. For many people, a pull toward pain, control, or fear is tangled up with real wounds: abuse, shame, rejection, a hunger to feel something, or a need to hold the controls so they cannot be hurt again. The counterfeit offers to replay the wound under controlled conditions in the hope of mastering it. But replaying a wound rehearses it. It does not heal it.

Healing comes from another direction. The Lord “heals the brokenhearted and binds up their wounds” (Psalm 147:3). Jesus was sent to “bind up the brokenhearted” and to proclaim freedom to captives (Isaiah 61:1; Luke 4:18). The Good Samaritan bandaged the wounded man’s wounds (Luke 10:34). Jesus never ties anyone down.

VIIITwo Kinds of Binding
  • Satan binds. The woman in Luke 13:10-16 was bound by Satan for eighteen years. Jesus says, “Shouldn’t she be released from this bondage?” In Mark 5:1-15 the man among the tombs is chained and cuts himself with stones. After Jesus, he is found clothed, seated and in his right mind.
  • Jesus heals. (Psalm 147:3; Isaiah 61:1)
  • God refuses the language of mastery in marriage. In Hosea 2:16 God says that in the day of restoration His bride will call Him “my husband” (ishi) and no longer “my master” (baali). He then promises to let her “lie down in safety” (2:18).
  • We are not to be mastered or enslaved. “I will not be mastered by anything” (1 Corinthians 6:12). “Do not become slaves of men” (1 Corinthians 7:23). “For freedom, Christ set us free” (Galatians 5:1). We already have a Master, a gentle, humble one, and He is the one who laid down His life for us (Romans 6:16-18).
  • Even Rahab’s cord was a rescue. The scarlet cord in her window did not hold her. It marked a household under covenant protection (Joshua 2:18-21).
IXHonor Modeled: Rahab, Ruth and Boaz

Rahab left a world of sexual commodification and joined the people of God (Joshua 2; 6:25). She is named in the line of Jesus, as the mother of Boaz (Matthew 1:5). It is no surprise that her son treated a foreign widow with honor.

In Ruth 2:12 Boaz blesses Ruth to be sheltered under the “wings” of the God of Israel. In 3:9 she asks Boaz to spread his “wing” over her, using the same word, because he is the answer to the blessing he spoke. God does the same to Israel at the betrothal in Ezekiel 16:8. Boaz calls her “my daughter” and a worthy woman (3:10-11). He sends her home before dawn to protect her name (3:14). Then he goes to the gate and pays the redeemer’s price (Ruth 4). His strength is spent on her honor and safety. That is the pattern God designed, and it points to Christ, our Kinsman-Redeemer.

XSide by Side

The left column is God’s design in Scripture’s own words. The right column is BDSM in its own standard terms.

AreaGod’s designThe counterfeit (BDSM)
FoundationCovenant: a lifelong promise made before God, rooted in agapē love (Genesis 2:24; Malachi 2:14).Negotiated consent: roles, rules and limits agreed on for each “scene,” and ended at will.
FearNone. Perfect love drives it out (1 John 4:18).The sensation or staging of fear (“fear play”) is part of the appeal.
PainTenderness, delight, cherishing (Ephesians 5:29; Song of Solomon).Pain and restraint used to create intensity (“bondage,” “impact play,” sadism and masochism). Pain is the curse’s language (Genesis 3:16-19).
PowerMutual belonging: “my beloved is mine and I am his” (Song of Solomon 6:3), with a husband and wife who are nourishing and cherishing (Ephesians 5:24-25).Dominance and submission (D/s): one holds control and the other yields it. “Master,” “mistress” and “owned” are standard titles. God drops that language for marriage (Hosea 2:16).
AttitudeHonor, cherishing, gentleness. Each person is treated as made in God’s image (Romans 12:10; 1 Peter 3:7; Genesis 1:27).Contempt, degradation and humiliation (“humiliation play”) staged as pleasure.
SafetyThe atmosphere of the covenant, present from the first moment.An emergency exit: a “safe word” used when things go too far.
The BodyOpen, present, relaxed: “one flesh.”Stress response and adrenaline, and the mind retreating from the moment (“sub space”).
The RootA gift from the Creator for covenant love.A reach for the right thing the wrong way, often tangled with wounds.
The FruitMore free, more whole, closer to God: the fruit of the Spirit (Galatians 5:22-23).A hunger for more intensity, not more love.
XIPossible Objections

“We both consent.” We should strive for positive connection, not just basic permission. Scripture asks a bigger question: Is it helpful? Does it build up? Does it master me (1 Corinthians 6:12; 10:23; Romans 14:19)? Two people can agree to something that still distorts what God made.

“Doesn’t the Bible say wives submit?” It does. And it defines the husband’s role by the cross: “love your wives, just as Christ loved the church and gave Himself for her” (Ephesians 5:25). Biblical headship means dying to yourself for her good. It is not a license to dominate (Mark 10:42-45).

“Doesn’t 1 Corinthians 7:4 give each spouse authority over the other’s body?” It does, and in a mutual, reciprocal way, aimed at serving and not withholding. It is guarded by 1 Corinthians 13: love is not rude, not self-seeking, and keeps no record of wrongs. Nothing in that passage licenses harm.

“The Bible never mentions it.” True, and that is why this is an argument from principle. Scripture also never names many things we recognize as wrong. It gives us the standards: honor, freedom, purity, fear driven out by love (Philippians 4:8; Hebrews 13:4; 1 John 4:18).

XIIThe Door Is Open

If you have lived in this, or been hurt by it, hear this: there is no wound too deep and no past too tangled for Jesus. Paul lists sexual sins and then says, “That is what some of you were. But you were washed, you were sanctified, you were justified” (1 Corinthians 6:11). Jesus says to the woman caught in sin, “Neither do I condemn you, and from now on sin no more” (John 8:11). “Though your sins are scarlet, they will be as white as snow” (Isaiah 1:18). There is no condemnation for those in Christ Jesus (Romans 8:1). Rahab, with her whole history, ended up in the line of the Messiah.

If you are married and hungry for passion, you do not need the counterfeit. Seek the real thing, for it is hotter because there is nothing to hide and nothing to fear. Understand that in this life, we all have things to unlearn and seek to replace them with what is better. “Love is as strong as death… Many waters cannot quench love” (Song of Solomon 8:6-7). God designed it, and He calls it good.

Perfect love drives out fear. And we love because He first loved us.

Each Scripture reference links to the full passage in the Holman Christian Standard Bible® (HCSB) on BibleGateway. The passages shown in full are quoted from the HCSB.