Sepia drawing of a tabby cat sitting tall with eyes closed and a contented smile, wearing a small spiral pendant.Rhiannon Welton

A Testimony

Forever Without You

Half a lifetime running from the light, a psychiatric unit, and what was still true on the other side of it.

Created Autumn 2026

There are songs that visit you only as sound: melody, percussion, a voice moving through the air and then fading. And then there are songs that arrive carrying a lantern.

“Forever Without You” by Evanescence came to me in such a way.

Because of the death of someone I cared about, paired with a long drive home, prayer, and whatever God does behind the scenes, this song wove together some things I haven’t thought about in quite this way before.

Memories returned of my long entanglement with darkness, self-deception, sin, spiritual hunger, fear, and the Enemy who promises illumination while leading people farther from the Light.

Not every lyric fits my history like a glove. Art beautifully permits people to get their own associations from another’s experiences. This song led me down a corridor, and in walking through it, I found doors in my soul that had gathered dust.

Forever Without You by EvanescencePress play to load the video from YouTube

The song can be found on Genius or wherever you find your lyrics.

IThe Source of Light

The song opens with half a lifetime spent running, not toward, but away from, a source of light.

Half my life.

That phrase lands with the dull, ancient weight of a bell tolling over a dark field. For approximately half my life, I was running, not merely from goodness, not merely from peace, but from the Source of Light Himself: Jesus Christ.

I cannot recall a clear childhood explanation of who Jesus was. I do not remember anyone sitting me down and carefully telling me about salvation, redemption, repentance, grace, or the cross. Yet something was there: a strange, buried awareness of spiritual reality. It was not formed well. It was not protected. It was not shepherded. But it seemed to exist nonetheless, like a small candle set in a window of a house whose rooms had gone dark.

Some memories remain painfully concrete.

I was exposed to pornography at five years old, an intrusion into childhood that markedly altered how I perceived life, people, sexuality, shame, and myself. There was an immediate loss of innocence, though I would not have comprehended it then. Something was stolen and a forgery, a distortion, of intimacy remained. It was a betrayal of the chance to learn what was best. It rather left an absence and a cold, lonely heart.

I was also drawn to witchcraft and darkness. The materials were there. The invitations were there. The books seemed to wait with their seductive little promises: knowledge, power, mystery, hidden strength, a way to become more than weak and helpless.

I was already struggling. Depression, self-hatred, suicidality. A kind of pride that was not confidence at all, but desperation, gripping at anything that could keep my head above waters that wanted to close over me.

Scripture says that pride comes before destruction, and an arrogant spirit before a fall. Proverbs 16:18, HCSB At the time, I did not know the verse. I did not know the Bible’s diagnosis of the human heart. I only knew that I was trying to survive myself.

Somewhere around the age of seven to nine, I prayed to Jesus.

I do not know why.

I do not know who told me to pray. I cannot remember the conversation, the invitation, the image, or the thought that might have brought His name to my lips. But I remember the desire: I asked Jesus for power. I wanted what I believed witchcraft offered. I assured Him, with the unexamined certainty of a child, that I would use it only for good.

It is almost laughable now, though it is not funny.

Human beings do not naturally handle power well. We do not simply find power and use it only for good. We bend it around our fear, vanity, injury, hunger, resentment, and need to control. Apart from God, what we call “good” can become merely a prettier name for self-rule.

Witchcraft is forbidden not because God wants His children weak and deprived of mystery, but because He knows the horror of power divorced from Him. True good is not self-authored. It is God-led.

I prayed this prayer more than once. I waited for power. It did not come.

Then one night, in the terrible logic of a child who believes silence means rejection, I told Jesus, “If You don’t give it to me, I’m going to go ask Satan.”

Did other children say things like that? Did other children bargain in the dark, unknowing that they were standing near a cliff? I still wonder. I know now that Scripture tells us that all have sinned and fall short of God’s glory. Romans 3:23, HCSB But sin does not always wear the same costume. It does not unfold with identical symbols in every life.

Some people flee into achievement. Some flee into appetite. Some flee into numbing, cruelty, envy, control, ideology, romance, rage, or endless distraction.

I fled toward darkness.

Did I literally go and ask Satan for help? Did I try to converse with him? Did I seek friendship with an enemy I did not fully understand? I cannot say with certainty. Memory from those years is scattered, like broken glass across a floor that no one has swept in decades.

But I know this: my thoughts, my actions, my inner world, and my nature increasingly bent toward darkness. I did not wear a sign around my neck declaring myself a Satan worshiper. I did not need to. My life was already moving according to the lie that I belonged to myself and could become my own god.

Half my life, I ran from the Source of Light.

IIA Damnable Romance

The next lines describe two people who always knew they were damned, from the moment their hands touched.

Satan knows he is damned.

He knows the end appointed for rebellion against God. And in his rage, he seeks to pull others into ruin, especially those made in the image of the God he hates. He steals, kills, and destroys, not always through theatrical spectacles, but often through quieter devastations: distortion, temptation, despair, pride, isolation, self-destruction, accusation, and lies repeated so long that they begin to sound like a person’s own voice.

Did I know I was damned at eight years old?

I would not have used that word. But I knew dread. I knew an ongoing wish not to exist. I knew repeated thoughts of death. I knew isolation and the inability to connect normally in friendships. I built inner worlds, detached, elaborate, private worlds, and became estranged from the rest of humanity.

That was not freedom.

That was bondage.

Jesus said that the person who does not believe in Him is already condemned, because they have not believed in the name of God’s one and only Son. John 3:18, HCSB This is not a smug statement for the religious to wield against the wounded. It is the solemn truth that separation from the Giver of life cannot produce life.

Titus describes humanity apart from Christ with unnerving clarity:

“For we too were once foolish, disobedient, deceived, enslaved by various passions and pleasures, living in malice and envy, hateful, detesting one another.”

Titus 3:3, HCSB

That is the human condition in its many manifestations: deceived, enslaved, living beneath a mastery we mistake for freedom.

In that sense, Satan and I had our own miserable, damned romance.

He promised power; I received confusion.
He promised identity; I received fragmentation.
He promised liberation; I received chains.
He promised knowledge; I received lies.
He promised a throne; I found myself in a pit.

I was hell-bent on rebellion against my Creator, though I did not understand that was what I was doing. And the enemy of my soul was hell-bent on destroying me.

IIIFire No One Sees

Next comes a line about too much fire to hold, and no one else who would understand.

There are fires that people can see.

There are fires that leave ash on the walls, smoke in the lungs, charred beams where a home used to stand. And then there are inward fires: lust, anger, self-loathing, envy, pride, fear, deceit, and a corrosive sense that something has gone terribly wrong but cannot be named.

The fires of hell appear in many places. They burn through cheating, stealing, manipulation, illicit desire, self-exaltation, and the ancient temptation that began in the garden: to be like God without God.

Would no one else understand?

Perhaps that depends on whether a person has seen the slavery in themselves. The person strangled by pride often cannot identify it as pride. I certainly could not. I mistook it for survival. I mistook self-protection for wisdom. I mistook my fragile, frantic determination to manage life for strength.

But Jesus opens the eyes of the blind.

That is one of the strange mercies of being born again: you begin to see the ruins that once seemed like a kingdom. You begin to understand that other people carry their own ashes, their own chains, their own concealed battlegrounds. The line, “No one else would understand,” can change with time into something humbler and more compassionate:

I understand that you are fighting. I too was lost and have been found. I too was blind, but now I see.

That confession echoes John Newton’s “Amazing Grace,” a hymn written by a man who knew something about sin, mercy, bondage, and rescue. “Amazing Grace,” John Newton

IVBuilding a Perfect World

The verse describes burning out of control, screaming until she couldn't breathe, and crawling into someone's soul as the only way to be saved.

Years later, I had a newborn baby and a small place of my own. Details blur now. I do not remember every circumstance surrounding a particular day, whether I had returned to college part time or whether my daughter was with her father. But I remember the rage.

I remember screaming at someone who I believed was watching me.

Not because I had faith in God then. I did not. I was screaming into the unseen as if some cruel observer were enjoying my struggle. I felt watched, exposed, tormented, and abandoned. And all the while, I continued in a deceived self-righteousness. I did not crawl into Satan’s literal soul, if such a phrase can even be said meaningfully, but I kept taking shelter beneath the enemy’s lies.

I tried to save myself away from God.

I tried to build a world so orderly, beautiful, controlled, and safe that my daughter would never inherit the misery I had known. I believed that if I made the right choices, monitored every danger, avoided every harmful influence, and built carefully enough, I could construct a flawless little world around her.

I wanted to become her savior.

But I was not God. I was wounded, deceived, terrified, and relying on tools that could never bear the weight I placed upon them.

VThe Good Shepherd

The refrain arrives early in this section in three simple words: she lost her mind.

I did lose my mind.

But I did not lose it outside the story of faith. My collapse did not occur because God was absent from my life. It came in the years following a dramatic turning toward Jesus, during a season when spiritual hunger, new belief, personal trauma, grief, fear, unprocessed wounds, and mental illness collided in ways I did not know how to understand.

My daughter had lambs as cuddly toys. I cannot remember how that began. Perhaps I bought one. Perhaps someone else did. But she had them, and I loved that she had them.

Then I came across a print of Jesus as the Good Shepherd, holding a baby lamb while the mother sheep walked close beside Him. I remember looking at it and thinking, I want this for her. It is too late for me, but I bet Jesus would be something good for her.

Why did I think that?

I had no Christian formation to speak of. I knew the broad cultural images: Jesus born at Christmas; Jesus crucified at Easter. I am not sure I had even fully understood that Easter was about resurrection. In school, I had sung the “Hallelujah Chorus.” I could perform the notes and say the words, but nothing had entered my heart. When I attended church, I worried about how I looked. I absorbed little. I retained less.

Yet the Good Shepherd was standing at the edge of my life.

I wanted my daughter protected from lies. I hated the Santa myth because it seemed like deception. I tried to shelter her from what I saw as the ugliness of modern culture. I surrounded her with The Sound of Music, with Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers, with Little Bear. I worried constantly about the world and wondered how I could protect her from it.

What I did not know was that no mother, no matter how devoted, can become an impenetrable fortress. Children do not need parents who can be God. They need parents who know they are not God, and who can point them toward the One who is.

In 2001, I met a Jewish man. I thought he would become my husband. I believed he was real, wise, and connected to truth. He taught me things such as the Shema (which I learned originally in Hebrew):

Shema Yisrael, Adonai Eloheinu, Adonai Echad. “Listen, Israel: The LORD our God, the LORD is One.”

Deuteronomy 6:4, HCSB

I wanted to convert.

I wanted the world I thought he represented. I wanted truth, order, reverence, history, and a God who was not merely a holiday decoration or a distant symbol.

Then, on Christmas Eve, he ended the relationship over the phone.

The loss devastated me relationally, but it also shattered something in my spiritually developing world. Still, I attempted in 2002 to become Jewish on my own. It is almost comic in retrospect, and yet deeply sad. I tried to remove all the leaven from my home before Passover, only to realize I had nearly nothing left to eat and very little understanding of what I was doing. I repeated the Shema. It may have been my first genuine effort to memorize something connected to Scripture.

Yet my Good Shepherd print remained framed on the wall.

And I found myself drawn to the film Mary, Mother of Jesus, starring Christian Bale. While watching it alone, I encountered a crushing realization: my life had been wrong, and I needed Jesus.

Not merely a religious symbol.
Not merely a historical figure.
Not merely the baby in the manger or the suffering man in an Easter image.

I needed Jesus.

In the intense immediacy of those days, I baptized myself. I anointed myself with oil. I read Scripture hungrily. I came upon Isaiah’s vision of the coal touching his lips and Isaiah answering, “Here I am. Send me.” Isaiah 6:1–8, HCSB I prayed alongside Solomon for wisdom. 1 Kings 3:5–14, HCSB

I was desperate to tell people what I believed was true: we need Jesus.

I was devastated by the realization that people can believe lies, including me. I drove for hours to tell my mother. I cannot reconstruct every decision I made in those early months, but I remember the urgency, the immersion, the sense that I had found water after wandering in a desert without knowing I was thirsty.

VIWhen Reality Fractured

Then came the autumn of that same year.

Only months after I had come to believe in Jesus as the Messiah, the One who could save both Jew and Gentile, I experienced what was called psychosis. I entered a psychiatric unit. The world became distorted, symbolic, terrifying, and unstable.

Within a 24-hour period, I thought I had committed the unpardonable sin. I frantically tried to repair what I saw as the brokenness of my daughter’s home. I carried her through the darkness of night to her father’s house. I was terrified there. I could not sleep. I thought the television was sending secret messages. Everything seemed unbearably cold.

I believed my daughter had said that her father had harmed her. I felt afraid and nearly mute around him, and like I couldn’t protect her. I thought he was destroying her life.

In the morning, I felt I had to leave and find help.

But I did not know where help was.

My daughter wanted to stay there. I was frightened, but I believed that if I could only find the right person, the right church, the right answer, I could save her.

I drove around alone.

I saw a car bearing a Masonic symbol and avoided it. Then I followed a car with an ichthys symbol. The man pulled into a grocery store parking lot. I approached him and told him I had done something terrible. He told me there were women at a church who could help me.

I was stunned that he did not help me himself.

I returned to my car and began spiraling through questions: At a church? Which church? What church is right? Who really believes in Jesus? They are all different. Where can I find help?

I drove.

The world itself seemed transformed. Sunlight over a bridge appeared radiant and intensified. The lake looked gloriously inviting. Then I wondered whether I should drive off the bridge into it.

My mind shifted constantly.

Songs on the radio seemed to communicate directly to me. I pulled onto the shoulder and waited for the Jewish man I had once dated, thinking he might find me. I began to believe he was Jesus. When no one came, I drove again.

Terror returned.

Bible verses rose in my mind, scattered, confused, distorted: Lose your life to save it. Save your life and lose it.

In the terror of that moment, I believed that doing the right thing meant losing my life. I could only save my life to be with Jesus if I lost it right now. I also believed that my death, my sacrifice, could save my mother and daughter from separation from God.

So I crashed my car.

The same refrain returns here, now at its most literal.

There is no elegant way to tell that part of the story.

Many people might reasonably look at an experience like mine and conclude that they want nothing to do with God if faith can somehow become tangled in a mental health catastrophe. They may see biblical ideas warped into weapons against a terrified mind and say, No. Never. I want none of that.

I understand that response.

Yet somehow, this catastrophe did not extinguish faith in me. It revealed how desperately I needed God, and how desperately I needed truth, wisdom, sound teaching, mental-health care, sobriety of mind, and grace.

The Bible says, “No weapon formed against you will succeed.” Isaiah 54:17, HCSB It also warns that God’s people can be destroyed for lack of knowledge. Hosea 4:6, HCSB

Whether one speaks of trauma, illness, spiritual warfare, ignorance, sin, or the permitted mysteries of God, like Job, there are things human beings cannot fully explain. I cannot claim to know every reason God allowed what happened.

But I know that what was meant to annihilate me did not have the final word.

The years after became a long pilgrimage of healing, learning, failure, seeking, despair, hope, regret, transformation, obstruction, clarity, delusion, and corrected perception.

I learned that needing God was not weakness.

It was reality.

VIIForever Without You

The chorus turns: she thought she'd fall forever without him. Turns out forever without him is good for her.

These words become almost inverted in my story.

For so long, Satan’s lies had supplied a counterfeit framework for life. They told me I could protect myself. They told me I could become enough. They told me darkness held forbidden wisdom. They told me I could build a world stable enough to escape pain. They told me power would save me.

But when I turned toward Jesus, I began turning away from the father of lies.

And then what?

Who would I be without the old structures of fear, pride, fantasy, control, rebellion, and self-deception? If I had built my life on sand, what did solid ground feel like? If I had trusted the serpent’s old promise, “you will be like God,” what would happen when I relinquished the illusion of being my own god? Genesis 3:4–5, HCSB

Would I fall forever because I had done too much?
Would I fall because I had believed too many lies?
Would I fall because darkness had been so familiar that light seemed unbearable?

God forbid.

Forever without Satan is good for me.

Forever without his accusations is good for me.
Forever without his counterfeit comfort is good for me.
Forever without his poisoned promises is good for me.
Forever without his false power is good for me.
Forever without his voice defining my worth is good for me.

Forever*with*the Lord is what I need.

VIIIStill in the Fight

The next lines are a confession: a promise to save someone she couldn't save, and an admission that she wasn't God either, and far from perfect herself.

There was a time early in my faith when I wondered whether repentance and saving Satan might somehow be possible. I had not yet understood the spiritual reality clearly. I thought of him as some hidden, heightened version of humanity, an immensely damaged being, perhaps, but still someone who might be restored.

My understanding was not sound.

Eventually, I became tired of fighting him, tired of his influence, tired of the repeating patterns of accusation and destruction. I prayed that he would simply leave me alone.

Yet temptation remains. The battle remains. Scripture says that our struggle is not against flesh and blood, but against rulers, authorities, cosmic powers of darkness, and spiritual forces of evil. Ephesians 6:12, HCSB

That does not mean every hardship is a demon, every thought is spiritual warfare, or every illness should be treated as a supernatural problem rather than a medical one. Wisdom requires discernment. Healing can involve prayer, therapy, medication, community, confession, rest, sound doctrine, boundaries, and practical care. God is not dishonored by help. He is often the One who provides it.

But I know the war between flesh and Spirit is real.

Satan still tempts.
The old patterns still call.
The lies still arrive dressed in familiar clothes.
People I love are still blinded by things I wish they could see through.
Humanity is still courted by toxic promises that masquerade as freedom.

And I am still in the fight.

Not alone. Not without hope. Not without a Shepherd.

IXBeauty from Ashes

One more line: to live, or to remember; to forgive and forget her.

The past is easy to remember.

The dark deeds. The shameful years. The confusion. The things done, the things believed, the things nearly lost. Memory can become a mausoleum where we keep returning to kneel before the dead version of ourselves.

But God does not call His children to live forever in a graveyard.

He gives beauty for ashes, gladness instead of mourning, and splendid clothes instead of despair. Isaiah 61:3, HCSB

That does not mean pretending the ashes never existed.

It means believing that God can make something living where everything seemed burned beyond repair.

I need to forgive myself, not in the shallow sense of excusing every sin or minimizing every consequence, but by accepting that Jesus’ mercy is greater than my self-condemnation. I need to stop treating the former version of myself as if she were the final authority on who I am.

I was lost, but I am not abandoned.
I was deceived, but I am not without truth.
I was enslaved, but I am not without a Deliverer.
I was blind, but I am not without sight.
I was dead in sin, but Christ makes people new.

The former self must not become an idol.

XLearning to Fly

And finally, the song's last turn: she stood her ground, there was only one way that would ever go down, and when he said goodbye, he didn't know she could fly. Neither did she.

Did I stand my ground?

Do I stand it now, day after day?

I think I do, but only because God stands beneath me, around me, before me, and behind me. I cling to Jesus. And when I am too exhausted, foolish, frightened, or weak to cling very well, I trust that Jesus holds onto me.

Nothing, not death, not life, not angels, not rulers, not things present, not things to come, not powers, not height, not depth, nor anything else in creation, can separate those who belong to Christ from the love of God. Romans 8:38–39, HCSB

That is why I can stand.

Not because I possess a heroic strength.
Not because I have fully conquered every fear.
Not because my mind has never fractured or my heart has never wandered.
Not because I have made perfect decisions.

I stand because God is faithful.

When Satan departs after another effort to destroy, accuse, seduce, terrify, or discourage me, I am reminded that I can rest in mercy. God lifts me up from the serpent’s low and suffocating vantage point. He teaches me, little by little, to see from above, not with arrogant detachment, but with the strange perspective of one who has been carried.

An eagle does not fly because it has never known the ground.

It flies because it was made for the air.

For the first half of my life, I did not understand the hope available to me. I believed the world was darkness, that I was darkness, and that perhaps darkness was the only honest thing.

But the Light was there.

The Good Shepherd was there.

Jesus was there before I knew how to name Him, before I knew how to pray, before I knew what I was running from, before I understood the serpent’s lies, before I lost my mind, before I entered hospitals and memories and regrets, before I learned that my own strength could not save me.

Forever without Satan is good for me.

Forever with the Lord is life and what I need.

Scripture quotations marked HCSB are taken from the Holman Christian Standard Bible®.